Domestic vs International Adoption: Pros, Cons, and Costs

Domestic adoption refers to the adoption of a child who is an Indian citizen and resident within India by prospective adoptive parents who are also Indian citizens and residents. International adoption, also known as inter-country adoption, involves the adoption of an Indian child by foreign nationals or Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) residing abroad, or the adoption of a foreign child by Indian citizens.

Under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, domestic adoption is governed by the Adoption Regulations, 2022, framed by the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA). Section 56 of the JJ Act, 2015 provides that adoption shall be resorted to for ensuring the right to family for orphaned, abandoned, and surrendered children. Domestic adoption follows a streamlined process through the Child Adoption Resource Information and Guidance System (CARINGS) portal, where prospective parents register, undergo home study, and are matched with a child.

International adoption is governed by the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Inter-Country Adoption, to which India is a signatory. The procedure is more complex, requiring clearance from CARA, the concerned State Adoption Resource Agency (SARA), and the receiving country's central authority. Section 59 of the JJ Act, 2015 mandates that inter-country adoption shall only be considered after exhausting all possibilities for domestic adoption, ensuring that Indian children are first offered to Indian families.

Pros of domestic adoption include a simpler legal process, shorter waiting periods, and the ability to maintain cultural and linguistic continuity for the child. The adoptive parents can visit the child's place of origin, interact with the agency, and build a relationship with the biological family if open adoption is pursued. Under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, for Hindus, domestic adoption also carries religious and customary significance, with the adopted child being treated as a natural-born child for all purposes, including inheritance under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

Another advantage is the lower regulatory burden. Domestic adoption does not require clearance from foreign central authorities, and the child's citizenship and legal status remain straightforward. The adoptive parents can also access post-adoption support services more easily within India.

Cons of domestic adoption include the possibility of longer waiting periods for healthy infants, as the demand often exceeds the supply of adoptable children. Prospective parents may face emotional challenges if the biological family reclaims the child during the statutory reconsideration period. Under the Adoption Regulations, 2022, a child declared legally free for adoption can be reclaimed by biological parents within 60 days of surrender, which can cause distress to prospective adoptive parents.

Additionally, domestic adoption may involve dealing with state-specific procedures and varying efficiency levels of District Child Protection Units (DCPU) and Specialised Adoption Agencies (SAAs). The process, while simpler than international adoption, still requires patience and compliance with multiple statutory requirements.

Pros of international adoption include the opportunity to provide a family to a child who may not find a domestic adoptive home, especially older children, children with special needs, or sibling groups. For NRIs and foreign nationals, international adoption allows them to build a family while maintaining ties to India. The process is governed by the Hague Convention, which provides safeguards against trafficking and ensures ethical practices.

International adoption also offers the possibility of adopting a child with specific needs that may not be easily matched domestically. The receiving country's central authority often provides post-adoption support, including counselling and financial assistance for special needs children.

Cons of international adoption include a significantly longer and more expensive process. Prospective parents must comply with the laws of both India and the receiving country, which involves multiple clearances, home studies by foreign agencies, and coordination between CARA and the foreign central authority. The child must also obtain a passport and visa, and the adoptive parents must comply with immigration laws of the receiving country.

Another major drawback is the loss of cultural and linguistic heritage for the child. The child may face identity issues and challenges in integrating into a foreign culture. Under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, before the adoption is finalised in the receiving country, the child is first appointed as a ward of the prospective adoptive parents, which adds an additional layer of legal complexity. The process can take 2-3 years or more, and there is always a risk of delays or rejection by the foreign central authority.

Domestic adoption under the JJ Act, 2015 follows a structured process through CARINGS. Prospective adoptive parents (PAPs) register online, upload documents, and undergo a home study conducted by a recognised agency. After approval, they are matched with a child based on their preference and the child's needs. The adoption is finalised by the District Court or the Family Court under the Family Courts Act, 1984, and a certified copy of the adoption order is issued. The entire process is monitored by CARA and the State Adoption Resource Agency.

For Hindus, adoption can also be made under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, which allows a Hindu male or female to adopt a child with the consent of the spouse. However, this route is less common today as the JJ Act, 2015 provides a uniform framework for all religions.

International adoption requires the PAPs to first obtain a "No Objection Certificate" from CARA. The child must be declared legally free for adoption by the Child Welfare Committee (CWC). The PAPs then file a petition before the District Court or Family Court for appointment as guardians under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890. After the guardianship order, the child is taken to the receiving country, where the adoption is finalised under the laws of that country. The entire process is supervised by CARA and the receiving country's central authority to ensure compliance with the Hague Convention.

The key difference is that in domestic adoption, the adoption is finalised in India itself, while in international adoption, the child is first appointed as a ward and later adopted in the receiving country. This dual process adds complexity and time.

Consult a family-law advocate who handles adoption matters to assess your eligibility and guide you through the specific legal requirements. Your advocate will help you choose between domestic and international adoption based on your circumstances, prepare the necessary documentation, and represent you before the court or CARA.

---

This page provides preliminary legal information about India Law. It is not legal advice and does not create an advocate-client relationship. For your matter, book a consultation with a licensed advocate.